Compare Cheap Hotels in Palm Cay New Providence Island

"Staff was great and buffet was very good. Need more bathroom options near restaurants and an atm would be good. The hustlers on the beach are annoying after a while and saw a couple drug deals go down."

"The staff was very helpful and friendly "

"The hotel was enormous, it has tons of amenities and lots to do. Only drawback was that things were very far apart so lots of walking. Our room was large and beautiful, we stayed in the 2bedroom regal suite, perfect for families. However, the food was disappointing, especially for being so expensive. Seafire Steakhouse was our favorite restaurant on the resort and worth the money, otherwise Shake Shack was most reliable and tasty. "

"Everything was amazing no complaints"

"Just got back from the most incredible stay at Palm Cay in the Bahamas with four friends, and I honestly can’t recommend it enough. The villa was absolutely stunning—exactly like the photos (which almost never happens), beautifully designed, spotless, and truly luxurious. The private beach felt like our own little slice of paradise—quiet, pristine, and perfect for relaxing or long walks. What really made the experience next level was the staff. Everyone was so warm, attentive, and genuinely friendly—it felt like we were being taken care of by people who truly cared about our experience.And the food… wow. The Pink Octopus was a standout—every meal was delicious, and they had great options for all kinds of dietary needs, which made it easy for everyone in our group to enjoy.This was one of those trips where everything just exceeded expectations. I would go back in a heartbeat—don’t hesitate to book this place. You won’t regret it."

"We stayed in a two bedroom harbor view at the Reef. Had lots of space for 4 adults and one 20 year old. Room was clean and well appointed. Resort is beautiful and there is a ton to do. Loved the water park especially the rapid river. Marine life everywhere you turn and the dig is spectacular! Dining we enjoyed most was Cocodrilo, Marina pizza , and Good Lies Sports bar. We were not impressed with Carmines. While salad was huge and tasty, meatball in red sauce and rigatoni was watery and no flavor. Also disappointed in shrimps scampi. Worst was being totally forgotten at end of meal, waited at least 25 from time done eating till asked someone not our waiter to get our check . We did Finn’s, flippers and feathers was absolutely amazing and my ten year old granddaughter was trying to figure out a way to live at Atlantis. Her enjoyment made it a fabulous vacation."