Compare Cheap Dog Island Independent

"It's an older, more like antique kind of inn, well kept. Got character! Great all day coffee. A wrap-around verandah with rocking chairs to enjoy the sunset."

"Early Spring, so not crowded. Staff not present early in the week but reachable by message. Replies were prompt and adequate."

"Positive: clean and easy check in Negative: bathroom toilet (tiny toilet), tile, tub from maybe 1980s. Big gaps in door and thin windows where you could hear everything outside. Outside there was trash from the Blue Parrot that sat there for 3 days. BIG negative: got charged an additional $250 because they claim we smoked marijuana in the room but we did NOT! I asked for photo evidence and they provided photos that showed zero proof. We are disputing this."

"If you are looking for a great place to relax and fish without all the hustle and bustle, this is your spot. The house is neat and the kitchen is well stocked. The walk to the beach is easy."

"Arrived after midnight and still were able to reach a helpful staff member to help us settle in. Overall great experience and would recommend."

"Despite the crazy wind all week we enjoyed our first trip to SGI. The cottages are in a great location. We loved staying there. The only negatives were that the shared wall is very thin and we could hear conversations through the wall. We had 2 nights where my daughter couldn’t sleep because there were 2 little kids next door screaming and banging around all night. The cottage could use some fixing up a little too. There is space around the doors and our first night there someone was using the grill and the smoke was blowing right into the bedroom under the door. We still enjoyed our stay and look forward to visiting again one day. "