Compare Historic Hotels in Tavernier

"Island Bay Resort was even better than we had anticatiped. The resort is beautifully maintained. Our cottage was uniquely decorated, very clean and very comfortable. We loved the intimacy and peacefulness of this small resort. Because there are only 10 cottages, and no additional guests are allowed, it is never crowded or noisy. Just what we were looking for! The staff was extremely friendly and helpful. We spoke with Daniel, the owner a couple of times and could tell he and the staff work hard to maintain the beauty of the resort. We loved being able to use the kayaks and paddleboards without having to rent them. The beach view is lovely and the water is crystal clear. We truly enjoyed every minute of our stay!"

"There was construction going on at the building they booked us in, which was a bit bothersome but not entirely. The room was comfortable, the beach area and pool were enjoyable. Good spot for families."

"Clean room, great service, good location for upper keys experience"

"It was a very nice hotel, with a clean pool and room. We were able to park right outside our hotel, it’s far from the main road so no noise issues, you could rent out the kayak and paddle boards for free. The person that checked us in was very nice and we would definitely come back here again. "

"We had a great experience. Loved watching the sunset from the top deck. Great to cruise around in the electric catamaran. Kelly’s recommendations were great. We found the sand bar and the Dive restaurant at Mangrove Marina was fun with the live music."

"Nice quiet family friendly place to stay"