Compare Historic Hotels in Rye

"Overall, this is a very nice hotel in a great location. But when you pay this much, your expectations really go up. The room was large and the bed and furnishings were very nice, but the bathroom was very small with nowhere to set clothes while showering and the front desk staff was snarky about lending me an umbrella (“don’t you have one in your closet?” In fact no I do not). Other staff were much nicer and the fitness center is quite nice by NYC hotel standards. It is nice to be on a quiet street (by lower Manhattan standards) and we walked to Broadway shows, museums and Central Park easily. Perhaps I expect too much for $600+ per night."

"Very pleasant stay. Would definitely recommend. "

"The elevators are really slow and during peak periods can take you about 5-7 minutes to get down 19 floors."

"Excellent location near Central Park and the subway. Will stay again!"

"We were disappointed with the room allocated to us, as the wallpaper was peeling of the walls, there was huge crack in the shower tray and the carpet was torn and taped. We asked for another room, which we got and it was much better. The staff were really great about it and everything else. It's a pity the bar in the lobby area is not open now as it was when we visited a few years ago. It's a good hotel, but needs to be brought up to a better standard."

"Rudeness persist in the registration desk!"