Compare Cheap Melville Independent

"Would stay here again"

"Hotel needs a nice renovation"

"The Good: The sheets and towels were always fresh & clean, shower & hot water good. Parking excellent. Heat & A/C unit excellent. The Bad: This place is for anyone who only needs a shower and a bed. All 4 pillows on the bed rate the worst I have ever had around the entire world. I have no sense of smell, and I could smell stuff that I could not identify. No elevator which I was told up front so you have to climb a straight set of steps. I CANNOT BELIEVE THIS HOTEL COULDN'T AFFORD TO PUT OUT SOME COFFEE IN THE LOBBY OR THE "NOT USED, FORMER" BREAKFAST AREA. There is no staff other than a person sitting behind a window. The Ugly: Our room was a complete mismatch of furnishings. The entire building (including our room) is very old looking and worn out. Our bathroom door would not close and has patched holes in it. The owner need not respond to me. I think you should be ashamed at how cheap and rundown this place is. Jeffrey Lynn & Wife 04/22/2026"

"Ok"

"I would give zero stars if I could. The front desk person was extremely rude and unprofessional. When we arrived, we weren't even allowed to check in or wait-he told us we had to leave the premises because it wasn't yet the 3 p.m. check-in time. We politely asked about the possibility of an early check-in, but he was completely unwilling to help and had a very dismissive attitude. There was no effort to accommodate us, offer alternatives, or even speak respectfully. This was by far the worst service I've ever experienced at a hotel. Customer service like this is unacceptable, and it completely ruined our experience in this hotel and area. I would not recommend staying here. I felt unsafe with the hostile attitude and behavior and ended up canceling our stay and looked for another hotel."

"Gorgeous property, with excellent amenities. The restaurant on site was perfect for an evening dinner in a nice setting. Cute little market on site to grab coffees or quick bites and snacks. Pool was nice and warm, deepest point was 4 ft. so my son had a ton of fun using it and felt comfortable the entire time. Gym looked nice and there was a private movie theater with a current movie playing. Will definitely return when back in the area"