Compare Hotels with Tennis Courts in Mackinac Island

"There was hair left in the tub, and the tub did not fill past about two inches. Staff was great, food was good, hot tub was great. Only complaints were about the tub."

"The Winchester Whiskey Bar was great especially since the weather was nasty the day we arrived. The hotel check in attendant was unapologetic in telling us check in time was changed to 4pm even though our reservation said 3pm and we were eager to get settled and dry after a rough trip over the water in 35 mph wind with rain. There was also only two cups of caffeinated coffee in the room when we were three adults and no coffee downstairs, which was very disappointing considering the cost of the room. We had to ask for more, or go get our own in town, where very little was open yet. The room was great and our view from the balcony was awesome so overall we would stay again, just be more prepared for morning coffee."

"It was well take. Care of. Off season so not much activity"

"We stayed in mid October 2025 and would definitely go back. "

"Very nice place to stay, it was clean and quiet. The staff was nice and friendly. "

"courteous staff with wonderful breakfasts. It's a very old establishment and very comfortable. "