Compare Hotels with a Gym in New Shoreham

"Upon arrival, the gentleman who greeted us was extemly nice and professional. However, he didnt know wich room or area we were staying in. He asked if we were staying in the Farm house we said yes. He then began to ask if we were sure we wanted to stay in that room since it was two bedrooms and there was only two of us. (Absolutely this is what we paid for.) He took us to the farm suite wich i thought was very nice. Until he opened the door and there was another guests stuff in the room. He apologized, we all had a laugh, and then i pulled up my reservation and confirmed it was the apartment not the suite. He drove us back to the lobby to get the farm house suite key. I was willing to let that go, this morning we were trying to catch the 11:00am ferry. We stoped in the lobby to return our key and grab breakfast wich is listed from 8am-11am. We walked in at 10:20 asked the person cleaning the tables if we could grab some breakfast and were told no, its too late. So to be honest, this "resort" has no real food on site, they do 30-45 minutes of "champagn and nibble" in the evening, and breakfast for 2 hours at 8am. Note to the owner: Subpar experience for $500 a night."

"there was no beach view"

"Breakfast freshly made. The beach was right over the fence. Right in town but quiet. The cookies are absolutely delicious!"

"The Kathryn Sullivan room was nice and spacious. The bathroom needs some work with the tub being SUPER slippery and the shower control rather iffy... The rest of the room was great with a very nice full kitchen. Very nice AC and heat systems. No real view outside but quiet green spot on the island. "

"Wonderful time. Very comfortable bed. "

"Location is perfect. "