Compare Cheap Melville Extended Stay America

"Checking in was easy, friendly staff. Very clean room and bath"

"We booked a deluxe king room and the room was ok. When we checked in we were informed the air conditioning was not working. Our room was not that hot but the lobby area was stifling. The first night we kept hearing a loud metal grinding noise but thought it would be repaired. The second night it was worse. In the morning my husband took the elevator up to the next floor and discovered it was the elevator making the noise. As we were right next to it we asked to switch rooms. They were very accommodating and gave us a new room. It wasn’t as large but it was away from the elevator which was good. We were looking forward to some sleep when in the middle of the night a large picture came crashing down over the sofa. We were terrified at first and finally saw the problem. If someone had been sitting on the couch they would have been severely injured. The hotel is in desperate need of renovations. When we left (we stayed 6 nights) the air conditioning was still not working. The first 2 days were 80 degrees and this made the hotel very uncomfortable. I really feel we should receive some kind of compensation as I am a Hilton Honors member and we do book Hilton when we travel. "

"I have stayed at the Hyatt multiple times and this stay was a disappointment. In my room, the bathroom sink drained incredibly slowly. My TV only received a signal from one station. On the morning of my departure, housekeeping arrived before 9 am, knocked once and without waiting opened the door. Since checkout is 11 am I was surprised that housekeeping would let themselves in so early. I also never received a receipt for my stay. At the bar service was so slow I had to flag down a staff person twice to get a drink. A disappointing stay!"

"There was nobody at the front desk for about 2 hours when I was trying to check in….long and behold the front desk associate was outside in his pick up vehicle, which was running & parked in the very front entrance of the building… As I came out only to calm my nerves after sitting in an empty lobby for literally two hours. A gentleman hopped out of the vehicle, stinking like he just smoked not 2 but 20 cigarettes and even worse the STENCH OF WEED…sure enough that was the front desk associate. I STILL CANNOT BELIEVE IT He was high beyond belief, not making any sense what so ever and finally after a total of 3.5 hours finally I was in my room. "

"Don’t book at this hotel. I’m not a type of person who likes writing reviews, but this was a must. I don’t want people to have a bad experience, the same way I did. First, this place is like a scam, its not described as it was on the internet. The place is disgusting, the room and bathroom overall is very dirty, smelly (most likely weed). I literally breathe during my stays, I booked it from Saturday to Monday, cause I needed to attend a concert at the UBS Arena, and this hotel was the closest. I don’t recommend anyone booking their stays there. Besides of the dirtiness, you hear people arguing strongly and slamming things. It’s not safe to anyone, especially if you bring kids. The environment is not it. If I can rate this hotel to zero, I would. Bad experience overall. "

"Would stay here again"