Compare Cheap 4 Star Hotels

"I stayed in a seaview room and it did not disappoint If I had complaints, they were minor- I don't prefer small beds, but I knew I booked one & it was cozy & comfy too I am not a small person & the space between the commode & the bathtub was minimal to non existent, anyone larger wouldn't have been able to use the facilities Part of the lack of space was caused by a heated towel rack, which quite honestly, was a very nice touch The tub was fairly wide & deep with jets, but that was the rub, the jets did not work & reaction from staff seemed to suggest the jets hadn't worked in a long time I didn't figure out the shower, but was happy to soak instead, perhaps instructions posted might help Otherwise it was a beautiful hotel with a perfect location & lovely views The staff was very friendly & helpful There was not a lift (elevator), but the gentleman carried my bags up to my room for me so that wasn't an issue either I didn't opt to eat at the bayswell due to time constraints but the food looked & smelled lovely I didn't have a fridge in my room, but the reception staff offered to keep my smoothie in the kitchen overnight so it wouldn't go bad I realized later, I could have also kept it on the window ledge too Was a very nice visit"

"Parking easy, room very clean and comfortable, lovely reception staff at check in"

"The mattress on the bed was terrible for me (felt like a really old sprung mattress, with little support). No breakfast on weekdays, which is a pain. Otherwise the room and bathroom were fine. Didn't use the pub downstairs but looked fine."

"Stayed for 2 nights. Staff meds us feel very welcome and accommodating.. situation ideal for restful break in woodland surroundings."

"Melville Castle was amazing lovely atmosphere for a relaxing weekend beautiful scenery and surrounding area . Staff were excellent x"

"Gorgeous castle close to Edinburgh! So far the main areas are renovated and they are stunning. The aesthetic blends castle feel (gold mirrors, beautiful wooden buttresses, textured wallpaper) with fabulous modern touches (lighting and tiling). We stayed in suite 27 and it had luxurious touches throughout (copper bathtub, double headed shower, new tiling, beautiful new bed) mixed with remnants of the castle feel (tapestry headboard and ancient well (secured) . The bar was classy and had a wide array of wine and full bar on display. The dining room was gorgeous and we had a phenomenal dinner and breakfast. The library is a great spot to read and has a hidden whiskey room. Ask for the castle tour! So glad we stayed here!"