Compare Hotels on the Lake in Madeline Island

"The staff was exceptionally pleasant and accommodating."

"Wonderful location. Staff go above and beyond expectations... Seth, Millie, and Katy are all helping us track down a historical photo of our grandfather that was in the hotel in 2021! The complimentary breakfast was fabulous...and kept well stocked as well as cleaned up after guest spills. The on site restaurant had great deals on lunch, and large variety of beer and wine. Pool looked nice, but did not use it. Beds and linens clean and comfortable. Lake view beautiful from 3rd floor. No ghosts in 318 or 320 :). Thank you for a fantastic experience!"

"Affordable, clean, and very welcoming. Best hot tub I've seen in a long while. AND the views are awesome!"

"We stayed at Legendaty Waters for 2 nights. Our room was comfortable, roomy, and very clean.. The bathroom was large, very nice, with a walk-in shower. The staff was friendly and helpful. The 2 negatives are that 1) The pool and hot tub were closed for maintenance, and 2) The dining room was supposed to open for breakfast at 8am. At 8am there was no one anywhere in sight. The chairs were still on the tables. I don't know if they ever opened for breakfast. We were on a tight schedule, and because of this, my wife had nothing to eat that morning. We saw that they were open for lunch at Noon. The setting on Lake Superior was quiet, relaxing and beautiful! We enjoyed our stay and would recommend to anyone looking for a place to stay."

"Clean"

"Winter visit. Location is excellent- walking distance to town grocery, bar/ restaurant/ coffee shops and Joni's beach. About 1/2 mile hike to golf course or Casper Trail to snowshoe. About 3/4 mile to ice road vans. Plenty of blankets, towels, kitchen dishes, coffee pot, electric water kettle, dishwasher tabs, dish soap etc.Good communication from Connie. We had an issue connecting to the Dish TV. Connie helped resolve. Although the Dish TV signal was spotty all week. Picture would freeze or signal would get lost. We reported the bathroom sink dripped constantly & that there was a high pitch noise whenever shower was used. Coleen said they were in process of fixing. Perhaps the shower noise contributed to the hot water not lasting long. There was also a strong smell and taste from all water sources. You had to run the water several minutes until smell & taste disappeared. Microwave had a broken handle so must open delicately.Furniture in living room is worn & faded. The arms in chairs were dirty from use. Ottoman/ foot stool had a piece of fabric stapled over it. Furniture could use an upholstery deep cleaning or replacement. Balcony was excellent for views and space. Have stayed at other units in this building & this unit is quite worn in comparison. Functional, great location but could use some maintenance/refresh."