Compare Historic Hotels in Koloa

"Resort area and beach access was amazing; definitely worth the price of admission. Room floor was pretty dirty, bugs crawling around the corners of the room. The walls are PAPER thin; could hear the people next to us and their television at night. Could also smell the horrible broccoli that they were cooking one night. Will probably not book here again"

" Had a great time in Kauai. Hadn't been back to the island in 15 years. I have to say that the stay was made particularily enjoyable by staying at Castle Kiahuna Plantation & beach Bungalows. Our stay was in suite 89 and the supplies provided were all good. Nicely decorated and was very clean. Short walk to the beach that was excellent. Would recommend this suite as very good. Only caveat is that if you are the type that must have air-con , this suite does not have it. Not sure if other suites on the grounds have it. Breezes keep the suite very comfortable , so no problem for us. "

"The staff was extremely rude. There was a cockroach found in our room. I reported the staff member who was rude to me to the manager. All he said was that they will make sure he goes back into training. Then he offered me $120 dining credit. The staff member was so rude to my boys and me that we didn’t even feel comfortable going into the lobby or dealing with the concierge. We will never stay at the Sheraton or a Marriott hotel again."

"Overall property was clean, room was nice. Expect to be nickel and dimed daily for resort fees and parking but not receive service and value in return. A good hotel, but not a resort by any stretch. Least accommodating hotel we stayed in. Better value at the Whaler Resort."

"Would have appreciated better communication from the person in the office during my stay."

"This resort had a beautiful view and small enough where you don't feel surrounded by people. It was peaceful and the staff were very accommodating and friendly. We would definitely stay again if we come back to Kauai."