Compare Hotels with Pools in Fire Island Pines

"Hotel messy, mattresses all over the lobby. Rooms were fairly clean looks like they have tried to update them. Tv wouldn’t work , no one could fix it. Breakfast was very limited options. "

"I have stayed here several times. Usually it’s fine. But now that have a totally unscrupulous $500 automated charge for “smoking or vaping” which they will collect without even going in the room to check for damages, basing it off of a “state of the art” sensor that, by the way, will also get triggered by blowing out a candle positioned near the sensor. Will you have a chance to refute it before they charge you? No! Will they check the room before they charge it? No! Totally ridiculous, I expect a class action lawsuit against the Hilton Brand if they continue to use this policy across more of their properties. Bad form. I’d love to see what $500 worth of damage they have to clean up. Because I can tell you, there is none. They gave me a report which states the time that the room’s air quality shifted, when the PPM went up is EXACTLY when I extinguished a candle. I had extended my room for one more night and when I went to check out an in again, they informed me that they tried to charge $500, which just goes to show you that they didn’t even get in the room to check for damages before charging a whopping $500. If this happens to you, I recommend reporting it to the BBB. Enough of these complaints will encourage them to stop… perhaps they will just lose enough business eventually."

"A place to sleep that had. Clean room"

"The property and how they maintain it was excellent. However, what I found very upsetting was that the toilet kept getting stopped up and no compensation was given for that inconvenience"

"We love staying here every year. The staff always goes above and beyond!"

"Great place feels like home "