The Buffalo Lodge was a great place to stay as we were traveling back home to Kansas from Idaho. It was reasonably priced and the rooms were large and had the "at home" feeling.
The only issue we experienced was the Buffalo Lodge is located in Chugwater, Wy which is a town of about 175 people. So there are no restaurants, etc to get something to eat. There was a Buffalo Bar and Grill connected to the lodge, but unfortunately it is closed Mon and Tues (our stay was on Tues). So, we had to come up with something to eat that evening. Pastries, cereal, fruit, and yogurt was offered the following morning. Everything else was wonderful.