Compare Historic Hotels in Long Island

"Cocobay was amazing. The staff was so friendly and accommodating. We truly enjoyed every second of our stay. Would highly recommend!!!! "

"Beautiful hotel, nicely renovated. Loved the app to book dinners and excursions. Lots of towels and beach/pool chairs. Beautiful rooms. Wonderful sandy beaches with nice swimming area. Fun water toys ~ kayaks, paddle boards and catamaran. Nice a la cart restaurants with a variety of choices. Buffet and food truck were nice options during the day. Staff were very friendly and frequently checked in to see if we were enjoying our stay."

"I was very impressed with this property for the cost of the stay! The property is not super modern, however, the staff are friendly and the all inclusive aspect can’t be beat! I traveled in on thanksgiving and was pleased they had a thanksgiving buffet. It featured all the classics including carved turkey, ham, mashed, salads, desserts, sides, and more. The bar was open late with a singer and dj which was fun. Drinks were good - first all inclusive I’ve gone to that didn’t water the drinks down. In the morning I had the breakfast buffet which was good. The fruits were fresh, they also had action stations like the omelette station. The buffet employees working the stations (chefs and kitchen personnel) were really nice and helpful. I will definitely be back! "

"The staff was wonderful and the property was beautiful."

"Nice relaxing hotel"

"The location is beautiful. The room was somewhat spartanly furnished but perfectly adequate and very clean. Everything worked well with plenty of power points,a comfortable king sized bed and great showers (2) All the staff we met were friendly and helpful. The food was great and the bar lady made an excellent margarita. "