Compare Hotels on the Lake in Long Island

"most amazing vacation ever!!! clean room, EXCEPTIONAL staff that go above and beyond everyday, perfect location to go to beaches, town etc. highly recommend Hideaways!!!!!"

"Debbie is the best host ever!!! There were issues booking our flight and she helped us get booked. She met us at the airport so we could follow her to the cottage. As soon as you arrive at the property you know it's such a special place!! The grounds are beautifully kept with all sorts of gorgeous vegetation. The cottage was very clean, and we instantly felt at home. The decor was like shabby chic beachy, but classy not cheap. The kitchen was well stocked with different spices, oils, and even some food items. The screened in porch was so nice and relaxing listening to the ocean. The cove is magical! We saw nurse sharks, sea turtles, stingrays, and a variety of tropical fish. Every morning we'd head down to the dock and watch the sealife. The property is so convenient with a grocery/supply store and liquor store 2 minutes up the road. I cannot stress enough what a magical place it is. As traveling sisters, we felt totally safe. And there's so much privacy and seclusion. I give the rental and the host 10 out of 10!!!!!"

"Great Spot "

"Amazing stay for my husband and I! The house is great, restaurants in walking distance, Jolly Hall beach is in walking distance and is one of the prettiest beaches. You have access to the resort which was great especially since we could borrow kayaks and paddle boards. The hosts were super helpful and responsive. Great stay overall, I highly recommend it! "

"Everything and everyone is great!"

"The staff was amazing - gracious and kind. The propery itself could use basic maintenance - paint, simple landscaping, replacement of broken exterior items."