Compare Fishing Resorts & Hotels in Long Island

"The views around the island including the hideaways was just amazing, great staff and clean rooms. "

"My partner and I had a blast. It was breathtaking! Staff was very professional especially the property manager, she was very pleasant. Food was great, the views were great, the room was cozy. Overall 10/10."

"Here’s a polished version that keeps your tone but tightens it up and smooths the flow:We loved our 6-night stay at this magical beachfront property in Exuma. The home had every amenity we could possibly need, and the kitchen was fully stocked with all the cookware and utensils. Everything was immaculate, and the beds were incredibly comfortable. One of our favorite things was being able to relax on the couch with a book while looking out at the ocean.We spent most of our time outdoors, enjoying the crystal-clear blue water and taking the kayaks out each day. One morning, we even spotted a turtle, which was such a special experience.Jack was extremely helpful and provided great recommendations and information throughout our stay. He was a gracious host, and his manager, Kay, made arrival seamless by helping us get checked in and stocking the house with groceries ahead of time—it made settling in so easy.We would absolutely stay at Two Turtles again on our next trip to this beautiful, turquoise-water island."

"Villa was spacious, beds super comfortable. View was beautiful and the beach is stunning. Great location. "

"Baywatch Cottage – Long Island, Bahamas April 2–10An outstanding stay from start to finish. Debbie and Phillip are exceptional hosts. They met us at Stella Maris Airport and escorted us directly to the cottage. Cozy, comfortable, and right on the bay, Baywatch delivers exactly what you're looking for if you want to unplug and recharge.Long Island itself is a gem. Up north: the Columbus Monument, the stunning beach at Cape Santa Maria, and rum punches with Shawn at the Busted Bridge. Down south: Gordon's Settlement, another gorgeous white-sand beach with turquoise water, and great conversation (and rum punches) with Earnest, who knows this island inside and out. In between, don't miss Dean's Blue Hole, the Shrimp Hole, and stops at the Vantage Point (ask for Ash), Dapple, Tiny's, Chez Pierre (excellent meal), Harbour Club, Sou' Side, and Letta's.Bahama Mama Debbie and Phillip will take great care of you. Highly recommend."

"I can’t say enough great things about this property and the hosts. The Villa was spotless, perfectly located and well appointed with everything you need to enjoy the beach and all that Exuma has to offer. It’s literally right on the beach facing Elizabeth Harbor and a beautiful sunrise each morning. The beds are comfortable (even the Murphy bed) which is a must. Our family of 4 were very comfortable with my 2 daughters sharing the Murphy bed. It’s perfectly located near Georgetown and some of the most beautiful beaches and cool restaurants. Michael and Roseanne are 5 Star hosts in every way. They were available to answer all our questions, make recommendations and give advice on any aspect of our trip. They even provide a daily post of the weather and best places or activities to make the most of the day! We loved this trip and much of this was due to our stay at Bella Vista. If you’re a first time visitor to Exuma or want to dig deep on all Exuma can offer, stay here!!!"