Compare Boutique Hotels in Long Island

Secret Bargains - Save an extra 10% or more on select Boutique Hotels

Get more for your budget and save up to 50% off select Secret Bargain hotels

Get even more value with CheapTickets Price Guarantee!

Change your flight without a fee on select flights

Check dates for Long Island hotels

Long Island Boutique Hotels essential information

Boutique Hotels in Long Island
Highest price
Cheapest price
Total number of hotels in Long Island
Popular hotels

Most Recent Long Island Hotel Reviews

OCEAN FRONT HOME WITH POOL,DOCK-STEPS TO MORIAH NATIONAL PARK

5 out of 5

Posted 8 hours ago

CheapTickets Verified Review

"We were looking for a nice home to get away and spend time as a family for the week. We landed, drove to get a week’s worth of groceries and planned to stay at the house for the week. We had a great time. Found all the needed cooking supplies, grill, coffee maker, etc. Great views, pool. We took canoes to other areas and snorkeled with equipment at the house. Jack is a great host, guiding us with things to do. It’s safe and everyone in town was helpful and welcoming. It’s a great getaway."

A verified traveler stayed at OCEAN FRONT HOME WITH POOL,DOCK-STEPS TO MORIAH NATIONAL PARK

Peace and Plenty Resort

5 out of 5

Posted 2 days ago

CheapTickets Verified Review

"We loved our stay here! Our room was super clean and roomy! The view was beautiful! Front desk attendants were very friendly and helpful as was the entire staff. Boat transfers to the beach club were awesome. The beach club was so much fun. Great location and delicious apps and drinks. Thanks, Andy, for making our day so memorable with our inflatable, food, drinks, kayaking, and island information! You can actually walk or Kayak to Chat N Chill and The Snappy Turtle! There’s also another beach club next door you can check out and we rented a boat from Minns right across the street, which took us to the most beautiful sandbars, turquoise waters, Chat n Chill, and The Coconut Club bar which had great, vacation vibes. There is a quaint little coffee shop right across the street that we visited. Peace and plenty location is amazing because the straw market is right next-door as well as boutique across the street and only a very short walk to the grocery store and liquor store. We went to the fish fry on Friday and tried out a few different spots. We also enjoyed scrumptious food at the hotel restaurant! Loved the steel drum band Friday evening! Great Exumas is gorgeous! Thank you Peace and Plenty for an h forgettable anniversary/birthday celebration!"

A verified traveler stayed at Peace and Plenty Resort