Compare Hotels on the Lake in Cat Island

Secret Bargains - Save an extra 10% or more on select Hotels on the Lake

Get more for your budget and save up to 50% off select Secret Bargain hotels

Get even more value with CheapTickets Price Guarantee!

Change your flight without a fee on select flights

Featured Cat Island Hotels on the Lake

Sammy T's Beach Resort

Bennett’s Harbour Bennett's Harbour Cat Island

With a stay at Sammy T's Beach Resort in Bennett's Harbour, you'll be in the historical district, and 9.1 mi (14.6 km) from Blue Hole and 10.3 mi (16.6 km) from Port Royal Beach.

On private beach

Parking included

Don't see what you're looking for?

See all available properties in Cat Island

View all properties

Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

Cat Island Hotels on the Lake essential information

Hotels on the Lake in Cat Island	1
Highest price
Cheapest price
Total number of hotels in Cat Island	87
Popular hotels	Sammy T's Beach Resort

Most Recent Cat Island Hotel Reviews

The Point House Luxury 5 bedroom Oceanfront Villa with Cliffside Pool, Kayaks

5 out of 5

Posted 3 days ago

CheapTickets Verified Review

"We loved every minute of our mini vacation. The house and property were outstanding. The owner, Stephanie was amazing with her communication and travel information. Highlights of our short visit were the Healing Hole and the Hawks Nest Marina. The property was one of a kind with its own kayak marina and snorkeling cove. The house and property were the best. We loved swimming in the pool that overlooks this amazing view. The crystal clear water views from the porch was something we will always remember. The best was the sound of the ocean and the lights from the stars at night. This is truly a very special vacation spot that we would highly recommend. Thank you Stephanie and care taker Harrison."

A verified traveler stayed at The Point House Luxury 5 bedroom Oceanfront Villa with Cliffside Pool, Kayaks

Luxury Secluded Paradise 4BR, 2 1/2BA, Spectacular 360 degree Caribbean views!

5 out of 5

Posted 12 days ago

CheapTickets Verified Review

"Everything at the house and on the island was absolutely wonderful! The options at Hidden Treasure and Curly’s offered delicious, top-quality food along with refreshing drinks you’ll love. If you're dreaming of pristine white sand beaches, no crowds, crystal-clear waters, and a rich cultural experience, this destination truly has it all. If you're looking for fishing, Amanda had great recommendations—thanks again, Carl! And if you want to sail for the day, and Dave Calver Sails charter is near the island during your visit. Seth is an amazing captain and chef. Just a friendly reminder to bring some cash with you!"

A verified traveler stayed at Luxury Secluded Paradise 4BR, 2 1/2BA, Spectacular 360 degree Caribbean views!

Cat Island Paradise . Overlooking turquoise waters and sky, sunrise and sunset.

5 out of 5

Posted 2 weeks ago

CheapTickets Verified Review

"Stunning sea view from every window in the house. The photos on VRBO are not as good as the actual property. The house itself is very high end and great value for money. There is also the best snorkeling in the island and a private beach right in front of the house. You will definitely be happy you booked this one!!"

A verified traveler stayed at Cat Island Paradise . Overlooking turquoise waters and sky, sunrise and sunset.

Cat's Cove, Pigeon Cay - 2 Acres w/ Private Beach

5 out of 5

Posted 1 month ago

CheapTickets Verified Review

"Cat's Cove is incredible. The perfect place to get away--REALLY get away. The beaches are beautiful-can't describe it. Aqua seas at your doorstep with curious, colorful fish just offshore.House is stunning-just as pictured. Two bedroom suites at opposite ends, each with a bath. A third bedroom sits between them--Perfect for kids! The kitchen is fully equipped-even an ice maker (a true luxury on any island)! The beds are comfy and the rooms comfortable with or without the A/C units. The grounds are stunning &fragrant. You'll be visited on the patio/tiki by curious lizards. Be sure to take time to enjoy the cool, shaded Tiki Bar. It's truly a dream. Owner Cat & caretakers Debbie & Tinny were helpful & responsive.Cat Island itself is amazing! No development here-it's pristine & unspoiled. The new airport and roadways seem to indicate it's on the way. The island people are delightful to experience.A few tips: The grocery stores have very limited supplies which can be a challenge. Only liquor stores carry alcohol and there are only a couple on the island.Brief power outages are common.Roads are in poor condition and little signage; improvements are in the works. No see-ums are everywhere so bring serious bug spray--with Deet.Kizzy's, Hidden Treasures & Da Smoke Pot are awesome eateries. (only 3 we tried)Watch for random goats in the roadway, they graze freely here.The healing pond works, if you're adventurous! Use the dock near the Greenwwood Resort."

A verified traveler stayed at Cat's Cove, Pigeon Cay - 2 Acres w/ Private Beach