The good (5 stars):Amazing property, directly on a back channel of the Madison River.Easy access, good communication from host, location exactly half way between Ennis and West Yellowstone.The bad (2.5 stars):Check-in instructions a little inaccurate - instructions said code was for key lockbox but instead it was for the digital lock on front door (once we figured that out, no big deal). Also, sign in the mud room requested no shoes in cabin. However, you don't enter the cabin though the mud room, it is off to the side. Had we not gone into it looking for a lighter/matches we would have never seen the sign. So, really not sure if host minds shoes in the cabin or not.Cabin pretty outdated. Beds upstairs very uncomfortable and loud (think it might be time to replace the box springs). Hot! (there is no A/C) If you're sleeping upstairs in the summer, good luck.