Skip to main content
Cheaptickets logo
  • StaysStays
  • FlightsFlights
  • CarsCars
  • Vacation PackagesVacation Packages
  • Things to doThings to do
  • CruisesCruises
  • Event TicketsEvent Tickets
  • DEALS!
  • Groups & meetings
  • Travel Tips
  • Get the app
  • List your property
  • Support
  • Trips
  • Members can access discounts and special features
    • Sign in
    • Create a free account
  1. CheapTickets.com
  2. All Hotels
  3. Shelter Island
  4. New York
  5. United States of America
  6. Hotels
  7. CheapTickets.com

See all 4676 hotels in Shelter Island

  • Brand New Waterfront - Chic & Sophisticated Unit # 702
  • Duryea's Sunset Cottages
  • Sole East Resort
  • Ocean View Terrace Inn
  • The Hedges Inn
  • The 1708 House
  • Charming 3-bedroom with WiFi and AC in lovely Southampton
  • SEVEN - Shelter Island Guest House
Previous1
2
3Next
Expedia Group trademark logo

Company

  • About
  • Jobs
  • List your property
  • Partnerships
  • Newsroom
  • Investor Relations
  • Advertising

Explore

  • Hotels in the United States
  • Cars in the United States
  • Flights in the United States
  • Packages in the United States
  • CheapTickets Reviews
  • CheapTickets Coupons
  • Student Travel Discount
  • Travel Blog

Policies

  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookies
  • Terms of Use
  • Vrbo terms and conditions
  • Do not sell my personal info

Help

  • Support
  • Cancel your hotel or vacation rental booking
  • Cancel your flight
  • Refund timelines, policies & processes
  • Use a Cheaptickets Coupon
  • Your rights as a flights traveler
©2025 Expedia, Inc., an Expedia Group company. All rights reserved. CheapTickets, CheapTicketes.com and the CheapTickets logo are registered trademarks of Expedia, Inc. CST# 2029030-50.
aca8c0ec-429d-41b8-9b4c-4a978db618788d834766-f336-4992-b8a4-ebe0e5a0c078